IPO Logo Home Search Browse About IPO Staff Links

Politics                     



CHARLES N. WHEELER III



Choice of a legislator depends
on the primary in some districts

By CHARLES N. WHEELER III

Between the Lillehammer Winter Olympics and Michael Jordan's spring training debut, one can sympathize with Illinoisans who might be tempted to ignore Election 94 until after the primary dust settles and the fall matchups are set. That may be a reasonable way to approach the races for governor and for the other constitutional offices. But in many parts of the state, voters who adopt a wait-and-see attitude toward legislative hopefuls will lose their only chance at a meaningful choice.

Up for election this year are 21 of the 59 Senate seats and all 118 House seats. In more than three-quarters of those districts, the nominee of the majority party is an almost certain November winner. Indeed, in many Chicago districts there is no Republican candidate on the ballot, while Democrats are equally scarce in some suburban districts. Downstate, each party took a pass in some strongholds of its rival. Party officials will fill most vacancies by November, but the candidates are likely to be sacrificial lambs — two years ago, for example, only two of 46 late starters were elected.

In most of the lopsided districts, incumbent lawmakers are running unopposed in the primary. In some three dozen of them, however, the majority party nomination is being contested, providing voters the only real choice they'll have among legislative candidates. And some of the primary contests have implications that extend beyond district lines. On the Democratic side, a half dozen Chicago-area contests will determine whether blacks increase their numbers in the House, while for Republicans, a handful of suburban races is renewing the perennial tug-of-war between moderates and conservatives.

Perhaps the greatest irony of the 1991 redistricting was its impact upon minority representation in the House. The plan's GOP authors crafted 18 House districts with African-American majorities of 65 percent or higher but left the door open in some districts for white candidates to win with the support of strong Democratic ward organizations. Indeed, whites took six of the 18 seats in 1992, for a net loss of two in the House black caucus.

Now African-American challengers are on the ballot for all six seats, with perhaps their best chance coming in two districts in which the incumbents — Reps. Frank Giglio of Calumet City and Clem Balanoff of Chicago — opted to run for Congress. Five hopefuls, including four African Americans, are vying for Giglio's seat in the 29th District, which snakes from the far south side into the south suburbs. Five candidates, including three blacks, want to replace Balanoff in the 32nd District, a large chunk of the far south side and a slice of south suburbia.

Of the four white incumbents seeking renomination. Rep. Barbara Flynn Currie of Chicago may have the stiffest test. The eight-term veteran faces Florence B. Cox, a former president of the Chicago Board of Education, in a head-on contest in the south side 25th District.

The other three incumbents — Reps. Daniel J. Burke, James W. Phelan and Thomas J. Dart, all Chicagoans — could benefit from multiple black challengers splitting the African-American vote in their southwest and south side districts.

In all six contests, turnout is likely to be a key factor, particularly if the black community is energized by Atty. Gen. Roland W. Bums and Cook County Commissioner John Stroger, who are seeking to become the first African Americans elected governor and Cook County Board president, respectively.

Republicans, meanwhile, are watching five suburban House contests in which moderate freshmen — four of them women — face conservative challengers. The threatened lawmakers include Reps. Carolyn H. Krause of Mount Prospect in the northwest suburban 56th, Ann Hughes of Woodstock in the far northwest suburban 63rd, Patricia Reid Lindner of Aurora in the far west suburban 65th, Douglas L. Hoeft of Elgin in the northwest suburban 66th and Judy Biggert of Hinsdale in the west suburban 81st. Like some other

6/March 1994/Illinois Issues


first-term moderates, the five lawmakers failed to support key items on the conservative agenda, such as a measure that would have required doctors in most cases to notify the parents of a teenage girl seeking an abortion.

For Hughes and Biggert, the primary is almost a replay of 1992. Hughes bested Steven R. Verr of McHenry by some 4,000 votes two years ago. A third candidate, Virginia D. Peschke of Woodstock, is running this time. Biggert beat James P. McCarthy of Hinsdale by almost 1,800 votes in a five-way primary in 1992.

Fighting among DuPage County Republicans is at work in two Senate primaries. Sen. Beverly Fawell of Glen Ellyn is facing Michael R. Formento, also of Glen Ellyn, and Timothy P. Whelan of Wheaton in the west suburban 20th District. In another contest with ideological overtones, S. Patricia Trowbridge of Downers Grove, a long-time county board member, is challenging Gov. Jim Edgar's former chief of staff. Kirk Dil-lard of Hinsdale, who was named to the west suburban 41st District seat when Sen. Thomas J. McCracken left to become RTA chair. In 1991, Trowbridge came within 2,300 votes of McCracken.

And in an unusual move for a legislative leader. Senate President James "Pate" Philip (R-23, Wood Dale) is strongly pushing RTA board member Kathleen R. Parker of Northbrook over two other GOP hopefuls, Robert C. Acri of Glenview and Thomas D. Filers of Winnetka, for the nomination in the north suburban 29th District. Party leaders almost always back challenged incumbents but generally stay out of other primary contests. Republican strategists, though, believe Parker has the best shot at ousting Sen. Grace Mary Stem (D-29, Highland Park) in November, the GOP's No. 1 Senate target.

Elsewhere, retirement decisions by a half dozen lawmakers, including House Majority Leader Jim McPike (D-lll, Alton), have triggered primary races whose winners are likely November shoo-ins. In these districts, as in many others, voters who skip the primary may find slim pickings come November.

Charles N. Wheeler III is director of the Public Affairs Reporting program at Sanga-mon State University in Springfield and a former correspondent in the Springfield Bureau of the Chicago Sun-Times.

March 1994/Illinois Issues/7


Illinois Periodicals Online (IPO) is a digital imaging project at the Northern Illinois University Libraries funded by the Illinois State Library
Sam S. Manivong, Illinois Periodicals Online Coordinator