CONSTRUCTION OF A CITIZEN SURVEY
By JERRY W. SHIRK
Receiving feedback is important for any organization. The private sector has the luxury in most cases to
watch their sales figures. If people are unhappy with
their product or services then they will cease to buy it
and sales will decrease. The public sector does not have
this luxury. Whether the service is good or not, people
of every community actually have little choice as to
who will police their streets or collect their refuse.
However, there are methods to determine the opinions and attitudes of a community. Once this information is compiled the results can be used to analyze a
program's effectiveness and efficiency. These surveys
can also help managers determine citizens perceptions
of particular departments and possible needs that have
not yet been met.
One such method that has been used in many communities is the Citizen Survey. If the survey is constructed properly they can yield a great amount of
information. However, if they are not constructed
properly, the results can be misinterpreted and abused.
The following information will help assist city staff or
elected officials develop a survey to gain feedback
concerning their services.
Questions are classified into two categories, (1) factual and (2) opinion and attitude questions. Factual
questions are those objective questions that elicit background information such as age, gender, income
bracket etc. By obtaining background information it is
easier to determine attitudes and behaviors of different
social groups.
Opinion and attitude questions are much more difficult to construct and must be carefully warded. An
attitude refers to a mental feeling or position towards
something. For example someone's prejudices or convictions. An opinion is the actual expression of an attitude. If a citizen were to state that, "There is a great
need to preserve older housing within a community," it
would be an opinion against possible demolition of
older structures. But, the persons attitude could be
more general, possibly towards preserving all older
structures and a belief against commercial development in older neighborhoods.
There may be no reason or need to solicit citizens
attitudes in most communities. But, their opinions can
be useful. Constructing a questionnaire that will determine a persons attitude is much more difficult and
should be done by someone with expertise in the field.
Opinion surveys can be constructed by city staff
members.
There are basically three types of question structures, (1) closed-ended questions (2) open-ended questions and (3) contingency questions. In a closed-ended
question the respondents are given a set of answers to
choose from. These are used if the survey question
wants the respondent to express an agreement or disagreement with a subject. For example:
"The police department is doing all it can to prevent drug sales in the downtown area?"
_____Strongly agree
_____Agree
_____Disagree
_____Strongly disagree
An open-ended question can help determine how
the respondent arrived at the particular response. This
enables a respondent to express their views without
being forced to choose among certain answers. An open
and closed-ended question can be used together. After
the preceding question you can ask the respondent to
explain further. For example, if a respondent answered
"strongly disagree" they would be able to explain their
answer by stating that they believe there are not enough
patrol cars in the downtown area to properly watch for
drug dealers.
Contingency questions are questions that are relevant to some citizens but may be irrelevant to others.
You may want to ask a question concerning refuse
collection. Many communities may collect refuse for all
dwellings except apartment houses with four or more
units. These people must contract out for this service.
Therefore questions concerning refuse collection by
the public works department is irrelevant to many
apartment dwellers.
However, this does not mean you would be unable
to ask the question. Researchers use "filter questions" to
enable respondents to answer relevant questions. For
example:
3. "Is your refuse collected by the Public Works
Department?"
____No � Go to Question #5
____Yes � Answer the following question
4. "Would you rather have your refuse collected
once a week or bi-weekly?"
____Once a week
____Bi-weekly
The second part of this article will explain question
formats, question sequence, bias and problems to avoid
and the means of collecting data i.e. telephone surveys,
mailing etc., and population sampling. �
May 1991 / Illinois Municipal Review / Page 5